SMP Logo    
SM Publications
The Resource Center for Silver Collectors, Dealers & Appraisers
Home  |  The Guide |  Book of Silver |  Links |  Orders |  For Sale |  Forums


Book Review
(11/16/98 8:20 am)

By

Scott V. Martin
info@SMPub.com


 



1904
Unger Brothers Catalogue
Reprint
Published By
The Eden Sterling Company


         The Eden Sterling Company's Historical Catalogue Series continues to grow.   The latest addition is a 1904 Unger Brothers catalogue reprint that has something for everyone. Whether you are a collector/dealer in flatware, hollowware, jewelry, novelties or silver smalls or are a  scholar,  museum curator or historian there is something for you in this extraordinary catalogue.

         The catalogue shows Unger Brothers full line of 1904 Art Nouveau silver.  The depth and breadth of items represented demonstrates that Unger Brothers was one of the largest Art Nouveau American silver manufacturers of the period.   In this 201-page full catalogue reprint, the reader will find more than 3,200 items displayed, including 213 pieces of flatware, 900 pieces of jewelry, 207 pieces of hollowware and more.  The index, which was compiled by Eden Sterling, summarizes the 3,200 items into 170 very useful groupings (i.e., brooches, calendars, flasks, flatware, hat pins, puff jars, needle cases, match safes, ash trays, etc.)

         In addition to the full catalogue, the reader will find a foreword by Ulysses G. Dietz, Curator of Decorative Arts, The Newark Museum.  He discusses the relevance of this particular catalogue to the recent Newark Museum Jewelry exhibition and further explains how very special and unique this document really is.  Also included is an excellent and brief history of Unger Brothers by Janet Zapata, Jewelry Historian.

         The original catalogue was "over sized" 14" x 20" and showed all items "actual size." This reprint is in a more convenient half size 7" x 10".   I am sure that some will have wished for a full sized reprint but the associated exponential costs would have certainly made this unique catalogue's retail price too costly.

         The catalogue is soft-covered and at first glance appears to be "Perfect Bound," leading  one to fear that overuse will cause the pages to come loose and fall out.  However,  Ben Randolph, the owner of Eden Sterling, pointed out that this reprint has a special "Smythe Sewn Perfect Binding."  This binding method stitches the pages together in small sections, and then the sections are glued to each other and bound to the cover.   He assured me that this will allow for significant use with never the loss of  a single page.

         You may have seen or been lucky enough to purchase a copy of Dorothy Rainwater's long out of print book Sterling Silver Holloware (published in 1973).  Her book includes only 81 pages of  the original 201 original Unger catalog pages. In her book, the pages have been similarly reduced.   I spoke with Mrs. Rainwater about Eden's catalog reprint.  She was very pleased that the public was now going to have access to the entire catalog.  She enthused about the importance of the Historical Catalogue Series and is looking forward to future additions to the series.

         By now you have come to realize that I believe this catalog reprint is a significant contribution to the silver world.  To add some objectivity I contacted several individuals for their comments:
 
 

Ms. G.,  NY (jewelry collector):
"... the catalogue is fabulously complete . . .  the printing is well done so that the designs are clear, and it is an essential resource for collectors of  and dealers in turn of the century silver."

Mr. D., NY (collector/dealer flatware):
"An excellent and much needed reference which illustrates the breadth of jewelry manufactured by this important silversmith.   ......   Very valuable in showing flatware pieces identified by the maker."


Gary Niederkorn, PA (dealer):
"[Unger catalog reprint] is excellent, my only criticism is that it was reprinted in too small of a format,  page numbers and original wording are hard to read.  A few pages are dark, but I am sure that is because of the size reduction as well.  But those are minor flaws, the information in the reprint in priceless to the dealer and collector."


Arthur & Judith Levitan, CT (collector/dealer):
"This reprint will become a mainstay not only for Unger collectors, but also for American Art Nouveau sleuths. . . .   Just to know the names of some of the more puzzling pieces is a special contribution of this publication. .... However, the decision to shrink it fully 50 percent I believe to be an unfortunate one. .... " 


Ms. B., Union, NJ (dealer):
"At first I was sure that the reduced size of the original type was going to be impossible to read but to my surprise the high quality printing allows you to clearly read the reduced type size."


Richard Kurtzman, NJ (dealer):
"Some of the items appear a little too dark...... but it is nice to finally have the whole catalogue.   I would have preferred to have it full size. But on the other hand, the smaller size is easier to take to shows.   Hey! Maybe they should have done it in both sizes — I would have bought both."


 Christie Romero (Author, Warman's Jewelry):
"I . . . find it to be a fascinating resource for historians, dealers and collectors. The quantity and variety of items made by the firm are astounding. As a jewelry historian, my only disappointment is that the 50% reduction in size has made the details of the smaller jewelry items, such as scarf pins and small brooches, difficult to see. However, I realize the impracticality of a full size reprint."


Carolyn of Carman's Collectables, NJ (dealer):
"To my surprise, I found the small size of the catalog very convenient when I had a piece of silver in my hand to identify and verify it as truly an Unger piece. The magnifier was already in my hand for the actual silver piece and I could easily use it to find the confirmation in the catalog."

        The importance of this catalogue should not be minimized. Consider this: the catalog was originally printed in 1904. By 1910 fashions/styles were changing from Art Nouveau to the simpler "emerging rectilinear styles."  So by 1910 Unger Brothers had started to discontinue production of most of the items in this catalogue, and destroyed the dies for these objects.  Then, just a few years later (1916-19), Unger Brothers was out of business.   Without this catalog we might never have the opportunity to appreciate all that was available from America's leading Art Nouveau silver manufacturer.

        Sure, there are a few minor things that I could criticize, mostly because I might have approached the reproduction of the catalog a bit differently.   But this amounts to nothing more than a difference of opinion and should not detract from the contribution this catalogue reprint makes to silverphiles everywhere.


Scott V. Martin is an author, lecturer, and entrepreneur.  Mr. Martin has a BFA in Interdisciplinary Studies from the California Institute of the Arts and is a graduate of New York University's Appraisal Studies Program in Fine and Decorative Arts.  His publications include a silver exhibition checklist for the Museum of the City of New York, The Guide To Evaluating Gold And Silver Objects For Appraisers, Dealers & Collectors and The Book of Silver; Flatware Silver Marks & Patterns.  Mr. Martin was a founding board member and past Secretary of the New York Silver Society.  Currently Mr. Martin is working on new book and is Vice President of SM Publications.

Contact: SM Publications, 353 West 56th Street, NYC, NY 10019   212-246-5060

This article and associated material is protected under international copyright law, and may not be reproduced in whole or in part in any form without the expressed written permission of the author.


|    Home    |    Order    |    The Guide to Evaluating Gold & Silver Objects    |    The Book of Silver    |    Chat room    |
|   Update BOS Registration    |   Silver Gallery    |   For Sale    |   Our Wants List    |   Silver Dealers    |   Speakers Bureau    |  
|   Silversmiths    |   How to set a table    |   Shows    |   SM P    |   Silver News    |   Spot Silver/Gold prices    |  
© 1998 SM Publications, All Rights Reserved.
Legal & Privacy Notices